Let's start with the surprise hit, (at least in my estimation), Pan's Labyrinth.
The movie was chosen by Rita who identified with the little girl in the film, remembering her life in the Dominican Republic during Trujillo's reign. She loved the movie when she first saw it and wanted to share it with us all.
The lowest grade Pan's Labyrinth received was a C from Zanetta. She didn't like the mix of fantasy and reality and felt that character development wasn't consistently good. She "got bored". Carl's take on the movie was almost exactly the opposite. Giving the film an A because he thought the film "worked with the mix of fantasy and reality", and that the "child's vision was well incorporated in the film". He also felt that the Captain was the most intriguing character in the movie.
David thought that the technical aspects of the film were exceptional but didn't think the story was compelling enough and didn't answer why the child was driven into a fantasy world.
Other HMC member comments included: "It was full of mythology, complexity, intrigue" (Stephanie); "Didn't like the ending" (Nero); "I got sucked in" (Kathi).
Here are the individual ratings for Pan's Labyrinth:
- Rita A+
- John A
- Yvonne A
- Stephanie A+
- Ed A-
- David B+
- Carl A
- Rylona A+
- Lori A
- Nero A
- Ron A
- Kathi A
- Harold B
- Hope B+
- Ramona B
- Valerie B
- Zanetta C
The Great Debaters
For the second time in two months a Denzel Washington film was selected, only this time Zanetta had nothing to do with it. Ed chose the film this time because it had two African American Oscar winners in starring roles. (When will we get to see that again?) Denzel also directed it and the subject matter is one that is close to most of our hearts. As a predominantly African American group meeting in the middle of Harlem, it was unlikely that the movie was not going to be seen. But that doesn't mean it would automatically get the high rating it received.
The lowest rating The Great Debaters received was a B but obviously even those who graded it that way enjoyed the film.
This is the kind of movie which as Lori said, "tends to make us think about the theme rather than the movie".
But beyond the social factors that gave value to the film, it also had its own merits as a piece of cinema. Rylona liked that it integrated what was happening at the time while juxtaposing the accomplishments of the students. The film managed to provide a lot of information about the America of the '30's, not just Black America, but also what poor whites were experiencing, the development of the labor movement while also depicting a slice of Black life that many today didn't realize existed; educated, well-to-do, accomplished people like the family of future civil rights leader, James Farmer.
Some HMC members felt that there wasn't enough back story to provide more background on the characters, that parts of the movie felt too much like a documentary but they still felt it was not only uplifting, but also an important film especially for young people. Probably the most telling comment came from someone who is not a movie club member, a 16 year old young man who accompanied Ramona to see the movie. He came away thinking that the story wasn't true because Black people couldn't achieve something like that. We need help.
Great Debaters Ratings:
- Ed A-
- Kathi A
- John A
- Greg A-
- Rylona B+
- Ramona A
- Carl A
- Zanetta A+
- Tiffany A
- Harold B
- Damon B
- David A-
- Stephanie A
- Nero B
- Valerie A+
- Yvonne B
- Zorah B
- Ron A+
- Lori B
- Rita A-
- Hope B+
No comments:
Post a Comment